Independent analysis
Center for Policy & Stability
Note · Education

A Child’s School Should Not Depend on the Wealth of a Zip Code

American public schools increasingly depend on local tax referendums for basic services, making a child’s education hinge on local property wealth and the outcome of a ballot.

Licking Heights High School located in Pataskala, Ohio is the only high school in the Licking Heights Local School District. The headquarters for the Licking Heights Local School District is located i
Licking Heights High School located in Pataskala, Ohio is the only high school in the Licking Heights Local School District. The headquarters for the Licking Heights Local School District is located i Photo: Sixflashphoto / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0

A child’s education should not depend on whether a community can pass a tax measure. Yet that is the direction American school finance takes when states leave local voters responsible for closing the gap between what schools need and what formulas provide.

The ballot can offer democratic control, but it also makes public provision depend on the wealth and preferences of a particular place. In one district, a levy can preserve what families regard as ordinary schooling. In another, the same request can become an annual struggle. The child experiences the result, not the fairness of the vote.

Local ballot measures regularly include taxes, bonds and school-budget decisions.1 Tying that much responsibility to property maps is too much.

The national picture makes the problem easier to miss. Public-school spending rose from $14,358 to $15,633 per student in one year.2 But the country does not educate children through an average. A larger national total does not make school funding equal.

Twenty-eight states gave high-poverty districts at least 5% additional funding.3 Still, the five highest-funded states spent more than $5,000 above the national average per pupil, while the five lowest spent more than $4,000 below it.3 A formula can narrow inequality without removing the local contest that keeps it alive.

New Jersey shows how policy can pull in opposite directions. Its school-funding law requires districts to raise a local share, while its property-tax cap restricts the revenue they can collect.4 The state can therefore promise adequacy and limit the means of achieving it at the same time.

States should fund core operating needs through formulas strong enough to make local referendums optional rather than necessary. Education should be a public guarantee, not a wager placed on a neighborhood’s property values and a ballot’s outcome.

References (4)
  1. Ballotpedia. Analysis of the 2024 local ballot measures in the largest U.S. cities and state capitals. 16 Dec 2024. https://ballotpedia.org/Analysis_of_the_2024_local_ballot_measures_in_the_largest_U.S._cities_and_state_capitalsContext ↩
  2. U.S. Census Bureau. Largest Year-to-Year Increase in Over 20 Years for Public School Spending Per Pupil. 25 Apr 2024. https://www.census.gov/newsroom/press-releases/2024/public-school-spending-per-pupil.htmlContext ↩
  3. Education Law Center. Making the Grade 2024. 12 Dec 2024. https://edlawcenter.org/research/making-the-grade-2024/Supporting ↩
  4. Education Law Center. New ELC Report: Fix the Contradiction in the Local Share to Improve School Funding in NJ. 7 Oct 2024. https://edlawcenter.org/new-elc-report-fix-the-contradiction-in-the-local-share-to-improve-school-funding-in-nj/Supporting ↩

How to citeCenter for Policy & Stability, “A Child’s School Should Not Depend on the Wealth of a Zip Code,” 17 November 2026, https://policystability.com/post/2026-11/a-childs-school-should-not-depend-on-the-wealth-of-a-zip-code/