Independent analysis
Center for Policy & Stability
Response · Education

Lucy Powell’s SEND test: make England’s promised support real before narrowing its guarantees

Responding to Desperate SEND families report councils to police in disputes over EHCPs, i News (11 Nov 2026)

Families turning to police over disputed SEND provision should push ministers to make existing rights enforceable in practice, not narrow access to them.

The Department for Education office in Sanctuary Buildings on Great Smith Street in London.
The Department for Education office in Sanctuary Buildings on Great Smith Street in London. Photo: Sebastiandoe5 / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0

At least 10 families have reported council officials to police over allegations that children were deliberately denied legally required special educational needs support, according to reporting highlighted by Liberal Democrat MP Chris Coghlan.1 England’s Education Secretary Lucy Powell should read this as a test of institutional credibility, not simply another dispute about education paperwork.

The allegations are not findings of criminal wrongdoing. Police responses have varied, with some families receiving crime reference numbers and others being told their complaints concern civil matters.1 A police report cannot substitute for a functioning education service. Nor should a parent have to search for a criminal remedy to make a support entitlement mean something.

The clearest number concerns the established route for challenging decisions: parents won 99 per cent of SEND tribunal appeals decided in 2024–25, the report says.1 That does not establish that every council decision is wrong. It does demand an explanation of why decisions reaching that stage are so consistently overturned. Ministers should treat it as an accountability problem, not an inconvenience to be designed away.

The financial warning is equally concrete: the Office for Budget Responsibility says debts linked to SEND spending could reach £14bn by 2029.1 A legal promise without a credible funding settlement risks becoming a contest of endurance. Councils need resources, but financial pressure must not become an excuse for withholding required provision.

Powell says her reforms will deliver earlier support without requiring a formal diagnosis, while the government is preparing changes that would reserve education, health and care plans for children with the most complex needs.1 Earlier help is the right ambition. But support offered through schools and support secured through an enforceable plan are not interchangeable guarantees.

The test should be practical: can children actually obtain the teaching, therapies and suitable places they need? Better identification would be progress, not evidence that entitlements are too generous. More mainstream provision would be progress only if it meets children’s needs.

Do not mistake fewer enforceable claims for fewer unmet needs. Powell’s task is to close that gap, not make it harder to document.

References (1)
  1. i News. Desperate SEND families report councils to police in disputes over EHCPs. 11 Nov 2026. https://inews.co.uk/news/politics/desperate-send-families-report-councils-police-ehcps-4886363Context ↩

How to citeCenter for Policy & Stability, “Lucy Powell’s SEND test: make England’s promised support real before narrowing its guarantees,” 16 November 2026, https://policystability.com/post/2026-11/lucy-powells-send-test-make-englands-promised-support-real-before-narrowing-its/