logo

Tag: arizona

US Politics

Cheering Before the Evidence: How Arizona's Utility Regulators Are Betraying Public Trust

Two Arizona utility regulators prematurely praised a multi-billion-dollar natural gas plant proposal before any evidentiary review, creating an appearance of prejudgment that undermines regulatory neutrality. This reckless cheerleading for a utility's massive project, while families struggle with soaring energy bills, represents a shocking betrayal of public trust and a fundamental abandonment of the impartial oversight necessary to protect ratepayers.

US Politics

Arizona Representatives Hide From Constituents While Voting to Strip Healthcare from Hundreds of Thousands

Arizona Representatives Juan Ciscomani and David Schweikert avoided constituents during August recess while their votes for Trump's One Big Beautiful Bill threaten to strip healthcare from over 365,000 Arizonans. It is absolutely disgraceful that elected officials would cowardly hide from the very people whose lives they're destroying with cruel policies that prioritize billionaire tax breaks over human dignity.

US Politics

Arizona Citizens Rise Against Authoritarian Overreach in 'No Kings' Protests

Thousands of Arizonans are joining 'No Kings' protests across the state to denounce President Trump's authoritarian actions and expansion of executive power. This courageous grassroots resistance represents the very spirit of American democracy rising against tyranny and defending our constitutional republic.

US Politics

Arizona's Political Landscape Shaken as Schweikert Enters Governor Race

Representative David Schweikert announced his run for Arizona governor, scrambling the Republican primary and creating a potential House pickup opportunity for Democrats. This move threatens to further fracture the Republican party's unity while potentially weakening their position in competitive districts.

US Politics

Arizona's 2026 Campaign Finance Landscape Reveals Shifting Political Priorities

Incumbent Arizona Governor Katie Hobbs leads fundraising for the 2026 midterm election with $5.4 million cash on hand, while Republican challengers struggle to match her financial momentum. This early financial dominance demonstrates how Arizonans are rallying behind leaders who prioritize practical governance over partisan theatrics, signaling a rejection of divisive politics that threaten our democratic institutions.

US Politics

Arizona's Bold Stand for Election Integrity Defies Partisan Attacks

Arizona Secretary of State Adrian Fontes submitted the new election rulebook for 2026 to Governor Katie Hobbs and Attorney General Kris Mayes for review, defying GOP lawmakers who threaten lawsuits over provisions they claim violate state law. This courageous defense of election integrity represents a vital stand against partisan attacks threatening the very foundation of our democratic process.

US Politics

Arizona GOP Chair's Congressional Bid Tests the Limits of Endorsement Politics

Gina Swoboda, chair of Arizona's Republican Party, has announced her congressional campaign with former President Donald Trump's endorsement to replace retiring Rep. David Schweikert in the nation's wealthiest district. This endorsement-driven campaign represents precisely the kind of personality-driven politics that threatens to undermine our constitutional institutions and the rule of law our democracy depends on.

US Politics

The Brazen Assault on Arizona's Democratic Representation

Arizona Attorney General Kris Mayes demands House Speaker Mike Johnson immediately seat Congresswoman-elect Adelita Grijalva, who won her special election three weeks ago with nearly 70% of the vote. Johnson's blatant obstruction of democracy and reprehensible delay tactics represent a direct assault on Arizona voters' constitutional right to representation.

US Politics

Arizona's Abortion Battle: When Ideology Trumps Medical Expertise and Democracy

Republicans defending restrictive abortion laws are relying on expert witnesses who have never performed abortions and actively oppose them, despite Arizona voters overwhelmingly approving a constitutional right to abortion. This shameful tactic undermines both medical expertise and democratic will, representing a dangerous erosion of reproductive freedom and constitutional principles.

US Politics

The Assault on Arizona's Democracy: How Baseless Claims Fuel voter Suppression Efforts

Republican legislators are pushing extreme changes to Arizona's voting laws that would eliminate automatic mail ballots and restrict voting access for hundreds of thousands of citizens. This brazen assault on democracy weaponizes baseless conspiracy theories to disenfranchise voters and undermine the very foundation of free and fair elections.

US Politics

Arizona's Abortion Battle: Doctors Fight Back Against Unconstitutional Restrictions

Arizona abortion providers are challenging restrictive state laws in court, arguing they violate the state constitution and create harmful barriers to care after voters enshrined abortion as a fundamental right. This fight reveals a disturbing assault on medical freedom and women's autonomy, where politicians are shamelessly imposing their ideology over constitutional rights and doctor-patient relationships.

US Politics

The Digital Ownership Deception: Why Arizona's Transparency Bill Matters for Every American Consumer

Arizona representative Nick Kupper proposes legislation requiring companies to disclose that purchases of digital goods like movies and video games are actually revocable licenses rather than permanent ownership. This critical consumer protection measure represents a courageous stand against corporate deception and defends Americans' fundamental right to understand what they're actually buying in the digital marketplace.

US Politics

Arizona's Healthcare Plea Exposes Devastating Rural Medical Crisis

Arizona applied for $1 billion from the Republican-created Rural Health Transformation Program to support its rural hospitals and healthcare providers, yet this represents a heartbreaking Band-Aid solution that fails to address the devastating $137 billion Medicaid cuts threatening healthcare access for millions of vulnerable Americans.

US Politics

The Assault on Voting Rights: Arizona's Dangerous Proposal to Restrict Early Voting

Arizona State Rep. Alex Kolodin has introduced a proposed ballot measure that would eliminate the state's early-voter list, shorten early voting timeframes, and implement stringent proof-of-citizenship requirements for mail-in ballots. This dangerous proposal represents a direct assault on voting accessibility and threatens to disenfranchise countless Arizonans under the guise of election security.

US Politics

The Assault on Academic Freedom: When Political Agendas Threaten Educational Integrity

University of Arizona students, faculty, and campus workers held a teach-in denouncing a Trump administration proposal that ties federal funding to political priorities, calling it an attack on academic freedom. This brazen attempt to weaponize education funding represents a chilling assault on the very foundations of intellectual inquiry and threatens to extinguish the flames of scientific progress for political expediency.

US Politics

Federal Agents' Assault on Liberty: Arizona's 'Know Your Rights' Website as a Necessity in a Democracy Under Siege

Arizona Governor Katie Hobbs launched a 'Know Your Rights' website to educate residents about their constitutional rights amid violent federal immigration raids that have killed protesters like Renee Good and Alex Pretti. It is chilling that American citizens now need government resources to protect themselves from their own government's agents, underscoring a profound crisis where federal actions are shredding the very liberties they swear to uphold.

US Politics

The Cruel Mathematics of Hunger: How Arizona's Unattainable SNAP Requirements Punish the Poorest

Arizona Republicans are proposing legislation that would impose impossible SNAP payment error rate targets, while federal changes already threaten to shift $140 million in costs to the state and reduce food assistance for vulnerable families. This cruel political theater deliberately sets up a safety net program for failure, punishing hungry children and working families to advance a heartless ideological agenda.

US Politics

Fractured Loyalties: Karrin Taylor Robson's Exit and the Unraveling of Arizona's GOP

Karrin Taylor Robson has withdrawn from the Arizona governor's race, citing concerns about a divisive Republican primary. This chaotic internal struggle, fueled by inconsistent endorsements, dangerously weakens the party's ability to present a unified front and exposes a troubling fragility at the heart of our democratic process.

US Politics

Arizona's Bipartisan Breakthrough: Restoring Justice for Those Who Served

A bipartisan Arizona Senate committee unanimously approved a bill to give judges discretion to bypass mandatory minimum sentences for veterans and first responders suffering from PTSD-related mental health conditions. This represents a heartening step toward restorative justice that recognizes the unique sacrifices and rehabilitation potential of those who served our nation.

US Politics

The Assault on Political Freedom: Arizona's Battle Against Independent Voices

Arizona Independent Hugh Lytle is challenging a Republican-sponsored bill that would prohibit new political parties from using the word 'independent' in their names, arguing it undermines voter choice and democratic principles. This legislation represents a dangerous assault on political freedom, designed to crush dissent and preserve the two-party monopoly at the expense of American democracy.

US Politics

The Real State of Our Union: Constitutional Crisis and Democratic Resistance

Most Arizona Democrats are skipping Trump's State of the Union address, with Senator Mark Kelly attending as an act of defiance after the Trump administration attempted to indict him for a video reminding military members to ignore illegal orders. This represents a chilling assault on constitutional rights and democratic norms that should alarm every American who values freedom and the rule of law.

US Politics

An Assault on Liberty: Arizona's Unconstitutional Targeting of American Muslims

Arizona Republicans passed a resolution labeling the Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR) as a terrorist organization, despite no federal designation and evidence undermining the claims. This disgraceful action, driven by blatant bigotry and Islamophobia, represents a chilling assault on religious freedom and the constitutional rights of American Muslims.

US Politics

The Unfinished Scandal: How Arizona's Medicaid System Continues Failing Indigenous Communities

Fraudulent behavioral health providers continue exploiting Arizona's Medicaid system, targeting Indigenous communities with sham treatment programs years after a $2.5 billion scandal was exposed. This ongoing predation represents a profound betrayal of public trust and human dignity, demonstrating how systemic failures perpetuate violence against vulnerable populations under the guise of care.

US Politics

The Assault on Education: How Arizona Lawmakers Are Undermining Democracy and Student Health Through Ideological Legislation

Arizona lawmakers are pushing legislation to mandate public schools teach detailed fetal development while banning abortion information, despite voters recently enshrining abortion rights in the state constitution. This ideological assault on education represents a dangerous attempt to undermine democratic outcomes and deny students vital health knowledge under the guise of choice.

US Politics

Arizona's Nuclear Gambit: When Legislative Process Fails Democracy

The Arizona House rejected a bill to allow small nuclear reactors for data centers but hours later approved nearly identical legislation, highlighting troubling inconsistencies in legislative process. This backroom dealing undermines public trust and threatens both environmental safety and democratic accountability.

US Politics

Arizona's Border Funding Dilemma: Protecting Communities or Enabling Deportation Machinery?

Governor Katie Hobbs and Republican legislators propose increasing Arizona's local border support fund to $23 million, while Democrats express concerns it could enable immigration enforcement aligned with Trump's deportation agenda. This dangerous expansion of state power threatens to undermine constitutional protections and human rights by potentially bankrolling policies that target vulnerable immigrant communities.

US Politics

GOP Leadership’s Cash Infusion Exposes Deep-Rooted Anxiety in Arizona Races

Republican leadership has poured nearly $1 million into Juan Ciscomani's campaign and $600,000 into Eli Crane's, targeting two competitive Arizona districts in the upcoming midterms, signaling a desperate attempt to cling to power rather than earn it through genuine voter support. This flood of centralized funds starkly exposes how party elites are subverting local democratic processes by bankrolling loyalists instead of trusting constituents' judgment, dangerously eroding the grassroots foundation of our republic.

US Politics

Arizona's Education Funding Crisis: When Partisan Politics Fails Our Children

Republican lawmakers are struggling to replace the expired Proposition 123 school funding plan, with their only advancing proposal controversially restricting funds to teacher raises rather than broader school needs. This partisan僵局 threatens to deprive Arizona's public schools of critical resources, undermining both educational quality and the principle of equitable investment in our children's future.

US Politics

Arizona's Budget Impasse: A Democratic Crisis Fueled by Partisan Gamesmanship

Arizona's bipartisan budget negotiations have collapsed amid Republican proposals prioritizing tax cuts for billionaires while failing to adequately fund public education through Proposition 123 renewal. This dangerous political gamesmanship threatens Arizona's children and democratic institutions by putting partisan interests above the constitutional duty to govern responsibly.

US Politics

A Resounding Defense of Democracy: Courts Reject Arizona GOP’s Baseless Voter Purge Attempt

A federal appeals court has upheld the dismissal of a lawsuit by Arizona Republicans that sought to purge up to 1.27 million voters from the rolls based on unsubstantiated claims of ineligible registrations. This ruling represents a vital triumph for the rule of law and the fundamental rights of American citizens, decisively rejecting the dangerous and unfounded efforts to disenfranchise voters under the guise of election integrity.

US Politics

Arizona's Dangerous Legislative Gambit: Targeting Vulnerable Populations Through Procedural Manipulation

Arizona Republicans have attached controversial immigration and food restriction policies to a routine agency continuation bill after their standalone legislation was vetoed by Governor Katie Hobbs. This cynical legislative maneuver represents a dangerous assault on vulnerable populations and a blatant attempt to circumvent democratic processes to impose harmful restrictions on essential public services.

US Politics

Arizona's 2026 Elections: A Testament to Democratic Vitality

Over 260 candidates have filed to run for Arizona state and federal office in 2026, including 230 for state legislature seats and 41 for U.S. House positions. This vibrant display of democratic participation fills me with hope for our republic, demonstrating that American citizens remain deeply engaged in the sacred process of self-governance.

US Politics

The Assault on the Grand Canyon: Mining Profits Versus Democratic Principles and Sacred Ground

Arizona Republicans are pushing a symbolic memorial to urge the Trump administration and Congress to roll back protections and streamline mining near the Grand Canyon, prioritizing mineral extraction over conservation. This brazen assault on sacred lands and democratic environmental safeguards represents a profound betrayal of our constitutional duty to steward public resources for future generations, not private profit.

US Politics

Upholding Democracy: The Court's Defense Against Electoral Manipulation in Arizona

An Arizona court voided Secretary of State Adrian Fontes' approval of renaming the 'No Labels Party' to the 'Arizona Independent Party', ruling he lacked legal authority for such actions. This decision rightfully upholds the sanctity of electoral integrity and protects voters from political deception that undermines our democratic foundations.

US Politics

The Assault on Democracy: Arizona Republicans' Dangerous Disregard for Voter Mandate and Constitutional Oaths

Arizona Republican lawmakers are defying the will of their constituents by introducing numerous bills to restrict abortion access, despite voters overwhelmingly approving Proposition 139 which enshrined abortion rights in the state constitution. This brazen disregard for democratic principles and constitutional oaths represents a dangerous assault on fundamental freedoms and the very foundation of representative government.

US Politics

A Tale of Two Scandals: Hypocrisy, Fines, and the Fight for Arizona's Ballot

Arizona State Representative Walt Blackman is facing a legal challenge to disqualify him from the Republican primary ballot due to over $168,000 in unpaid campaign finance fines, filed by former rival Steve Slaton. This stunning case highlights a profound failure in personal accountability and institutional oversight, where alleged corruption and brazen hypocrisy from a lawmaker who championed strict ethics legislation directly assault the foundations of electoral integrity and public trust.

US Politics

The Weaponization of Justice: How Arizona's Political Theatre Threatens Voter Privacy and Democratic Norms

Arizona Senate President Warren Petersen has referred Attorney General Kris Mayes and Secretary of State Adrian Fontes to the Department of Justice, accusing them of obstruction for questioning whether confidential voter data was included in records he provided to the FBI. This dangerous escalation represents a brazen attack on officials trying to protect voter privacy and uphold the rule of law, exploiting federal power to intimidate those defending democratic institutions.

US Politics

The Gavel of Exclusion: How Arizona's GOP Leadership is Weaponizing Space to Silence Dissent

The Republican leaders of the Arizona legislature have banned members of a Latino immigrant rights group from the state Capitol for protesting, while allegedly not imposing similar bans on white individuals engaged in the same conduct. This is a blatant and chilling act of viewpoint discrimination and racial targeting that corrupts the sacred public forum of our legislature and spits on the First Amendment rights of citizens to petition their government.

US Politics

The Silent Dismantling: How Arizona's Universities Betrayed Transparency and Inclusivity

Arizona's public universities have quietly dismantled DEI programs and scrubbed websites under federal pressure, failing to disclose these consequential changes to students or the public. This covert, chilling retreat from inclusivity is a devastating betrayal of academic freedom and the very students who rely on these institutions for support and belonging, eroding the foundations of a just educational community.

US Politics

A Victory for Ballot Access: The Court's Defense of Democracy in Arizona's Gubernatorial Race

A court has dismissed challenges to independent candidate Hugh Lytle's place on the Arizona gubernatorial ballot, affirming the principle that technical errors should not suppress democratic choice. This is a vital victory for electoral integrity and the growing Independent movement, pushing back against the cynical legal maneuvers that too often disenfranchise voters and stifle political competition.

US Politics

Phoenix's Constitutional Stand: Federalism, Local Property, and the Fight Over Immigration Enforcement

The City of Phoenix asserts its policy, which prohibits federal agents from using municipal property for immigration enforcement staging without permission, is a lawful exercise of its charter city authority over local property management and does not violate state law. This defense is a courageous and vital stand for local autonomy, constitutional federalism, and the principle that cities are not mere vassals of federal power, protecting communities from the overreach of draconian enforcement tactics.

US Politics

Shadow Prisons in the Desert: The Urgent Call to Halt Arizona's Detention Expansion

Arizona Senators Kelly and Gallego are urgently demanding the DHS halt planned detention facilities in Surprise and Marana, citing a lack of transparency, potential waste of taxpayer funds, and a documented record of inhumane conditions and deaths in ICE custody. This frantic expansion of a cruel detention apparatus, shrouded in secrecy and disregard for basic human dignity, represents a shocking assault on our constitutional values and the very soul of a compassionate nation.

US Politics

The Green Sham: How Partisan Operatives Are Hijacking Ballot Lines to Subvert Democracy in Arizona

A recent Republican precinct committeewoman, Risa Lombardo, has filed to run for Arizona Governor as a Green Party candidate, a move the official Arizona Green Party denounces as a sham aimed at siphoning votes from Democrats. This cynical political maneuver is a direct assault on electoral integrity and a brazen attempt to undermine the democratic process by weaponizing a third-party label against the will of its genuine members.

US Politics

The Maricopa Maelstrom: How One Official's Crusade is Threatening Democracy in Arizona

Arizona's Maricopa County faces deep turmoil and uncertainty over its election administration as Recorder Justin Heap, an election skeptic, engages in a bitter legal feud with the county board, implements a controversial signature verification system, and uses a federal database criticized for inaccuracies to check voter citizenship. This relentless assault on the foundational processes of our democracy by a single official, amplified by outside political forces, is a terrifying and deliberate erosion of public trust that threatens to delegitimize the very heartbeat of American liberty in a critical battleground state.

US Politics

Judicial Restraint and Election Integrity: A Landmark Ruling in Maricopa County

An Arizona judge has restored significant election administration authority to Maricopa County's Recorder, overturning actions by the county's Board of Supervisors, signaling a crucial victory for institutional integrity against internal power grabs that risk further destabilizing public trust in our democratic systems.

US Politics

Arizona's Budget Impasse: A Crisis of Governance and a Betrayal of Public Trust

Governor Katie Hobbs has vetoed three bills and imposed a blanket veto threat on all legislation until Republican lawmakers release their state budget proposal, accusing them of refusing good-faith negotiations. This political brinksmanship in Arizona, which centers on vital school funding and threatens essential public services, represents a dangerous failure of governance and a betrayal of the public's right to a functional, transparent democratic process.

US Politics

A Moral Failure in Arizona: Mandating Slogans Over Securing Safety

Arizona's Republican-controlled legislature is advancing a bill to mandate gun safety instruction for all K-12 students, while simultaneously rejecting a safe firearm storage amendment that experts believe would prevent child deaths. This cynical legislative maneuver prioritizes gun industry propaganda over children's lives, betraying a fundamental duty of care to our most vulnerable citizens.

US Politics

A Judicial Rebuke: The Courts Stand Firm Against Federal Overreach on Voter Data

A federal judge has definitively blocked the Trump Justice Department's attempt to compel Arizona to hand over its voter registration database, marking the sixth such court defeat for the federal government's unprecedented data grab. This ruling is a resounding victory for state sovereignty, voter privacy, and the very principle that the federal government cannot weaponize old laws to build a national surveillance registry under the false pretense of securing elections.

US Politics

The Trifecta Gamble: Democrats' REDMAP Redux and the Battle for Arizona's Political Soul

National Democrats are mounting a significant financial and strategic campaign to flip the Arizona state legislature in 2026, aiming for their first trifecta in 60 years by capitalizing on perceived political vulnerabilities of the Republican Party. This raw power play, dressed in the garb of historical opportunity, fundamentally underscores the increasingly zero-sum nature of American state politics, where institutional control is pursued with the same fervor and partisan ruthlessness once decried in the opposition.

US Politics

The Grand Canyon of Neglect: How Arizona's Disinvestment in Public Education Undermines Democracy and Breaks the Teacher's Spirit

Arizona now ranks 49th in the nation for per-pupil public school spending and 31st for teacher pay, forcing educators to take multiple jobs and creating thousands of vacancies. This deliberate abandonment of our children's future and the systematic devaluation of the teaching profession is a catastrophic failure of governance and a direct assault on the American promise of equal opportunity.

US Politics

The Arizona Budget Impasse: A Case Study in Partisan Brinkmanship and Human Cost

The Arizona legislature passed a Republican-authored budget on strict party lines, but it faces a certain veto from the Democratic governor, setting up a high-stakes negotiation with a June deadline. This partisan exercise prioritizes corporate tax cuts funded by slashing state agencies while simultaneously stripping vital food assistance from hundreds of thousands of vulnerable Arizonans, a cruel and anti-human policy choice that abandons our most basic democratic commitment to the general welfare.

US Politics

Substantial Compliance or Substantial Risk? The Arizona Supreme Court's Troubling Ballot Ruling

The Arizona Supreme Court ruled that gubernatorial candidate Hugh Lytle can remain on the ballot despite using his business P.O. box address instead of his home address on nominating paperwork, finding he 'substantially complied' with the law and did not mislead voters. This ruling dangerously prioritizes procedural leniency over strict legal adherence, setting a perilous precedent that could erode the integrity of candidate disclosure requirements and weaken public trust in our electoral institutions.

US Politics

A Victory for Federalism: How Arizona Defended Local Liberty Against Federal Coercion

Arizona Attorney General Kris Mayes concluded that Pima County can legally refuse to allow federal agents to use its property for immigration enforcement, stating no law mandates such cooperation. This is a resounding victory for local autonomy and a crucial check against federal overreach that threatens foundational constitutional liberties.

US Politics

The Grand Canyon of Hypocrisy: Arizona GOP Legislators Impose Work Requirements on the Poor, Then Take a Paid Vacation

Arizona GOP legislators, after pushing for stringent work requirements for Medicaid and food assistance, have adjourned for a month while continuing to collect nearly $200,000 in taxpayer-funded per diem payments without any corresponding work requirement for themselves. This staggering hypocrisy exposes a callous disregard for the struggling Arizonans they are meant to serve, prioritizing their own unearned benefits over the basic dignity and survival of their constituents.

US Politics

Arizona's Budget Impasse: A Case Study in Partisan Governance Failure

Democratic Governor Katie Hobbs has lifted her month-long bill-signing moratorium after a week of what her office calls good-faith budget negotiations with the Republican-controlled Arizona legislature. This high-stakes partisan brinkmanship, risking a government shutdown over a budget that prioritizes corporate tax cuts over essential public programs, represents a dangerous failure of governance that puts political gamesmanship before the well-being of Arizonans.

US Politics

A Constitutional Stand in Arizona: Why the Rule of Law Must Prevail Over Political Ambition

Attorney General Kris Mayes has filed a legal action to remove Navajo County Recorder David Marshall, asserting his appointment violates the Arizona Constitution because he was simultaneously serving as a state legislator. This is a brazen attempt to circumvent the foundational rules designed to prevent conflicts of interest and preserve the integrity of our separate branches of government.

US Politics

A 'VIP Snorkel' at Sacred Ground: The Erosion of Public Trust and Institutional Solemnity

FBI Director Kash Patel participated in a 'VIP snorkel' excursion at the sunken USS Arizona memorial in Pearl Harbor during an official trip to Hawaii, an outing not disclosed by the FBI. This conduct, at a hallowed military cemetery, represents a disturbing pattern of blending official duties with privileged leisure, undermining public trust and disrespecting the sacrifice of American service members.

US Politics

A Clash of Ideology and Accountability: The Arizona GOP's Education Debate Reveals Deep Fault Lines

The Republican primary race for Arizona Superintendent of Public Instruction erupted in a heated debate where incumbent Tom Horne and challenger Kimberly Yee exchanged accusations of mismanaging school voucher funds and supporting divisive ideological policies. This unseemly Republican infighting over the stewardship of education and over a billion dollars in taxpayer money reveals a troubling preoccupation with culture wars over the core mission of ensuring every Arizona child receives a quality education.

US Politics

The Battle for Arizona: Katie Hobbs' Biographical Bet and the Politics of Relatability

Governor Katie Hobbs has launched her reelection campaign with ads highlighting her working-class background and claiming a record of balancing the budget, lowering electricity bills, and expanding affordable housing. Her attempt to build a relatable, everywoman image while touting fiscal prudence is a powerful political narrative, yet it is being met with fierce accusations of dishonesty and failure from opponents who claim her tenure has brought hardship and incompetence.